Will hear only triple talaq case, says apex court

Appearing for the AIMPLB, senior advocate Kapil Sibal questioned how could Triple Talaq be un-Islamic when it has been in practice for 1,400 years.

"The scope of referring had all the three issues that was divorce, nikah halala, polygamy".

The bench is hearing petitions from individuals and organisations challenging the constitutional validity of the instant triple talaq, with the Centre supporting them on the ground of Muslim women's rights. The Supreme Court clarified on Monday, the day three of the hearing, May 15, 2017, that it had not closed the window to scrutiny of the two contentious issues, though it said that a decision on triple talaq wouldn't have any bearing on those two issues.

"We will keep them pending for future", said a five-judge Constitution bench consisted by Justices Kurian Joseph, RF Nariman, UU Lalit, Abdul Nazeer and headed by Chief Justice JS Khehar.

Triple talaq is the lone controversial way Sunni Muslim men in India can get a divorce.

The board has asserted that a practice which is being followed for 1,400 year cannot be termed as un-Islamic.

"Triple talaq is unconstitutional".

More news: Ash stuns in glorious gown on red carpet

Kapil Sibal however blundered again by saying that the cases being relied upon by Kerala, Madras, Delhi and Gauhati High Courts had observations from scholars who belonged to "the Ahle Hadees school of Islam and the Qadianis".

Even bigger blunder by Sibal on day four of the triple talaq hearing in the Supreme Court was when he said "triple talaq can not be tampered with as it's something the Qura'n is silent about".

As Rohatgi emphasised on gender equality of Muslim women including with their counterparts in other religions and in other Islamic countries, the court said that he was talking of gender equality, equality between religions and equality between the people of different countries and in this way, all marriage laws should go and civil marriage was the only course. The Attorney-General said all three forms of triple talaq - talaq-e-biddat, talaq hasan and talaq ahasan - are "unilateral, extrajudicial, unequal" and have to be struck down. The practice is a matter of trust so no question arises of legitimate ethics and equity.

He asked: "If there is a conflict between constitutional morality and personal law, which shall prevail?"

On Friday, the bench called the practice of triple talaq the "worst" and "not desirable" form of dissolution of marriages among Muslims.

The AIMPLB counsel said the age-old practice was "part of my faith and you can not determine what should be my faith".

"There was a discussion that whether Triple Talaq is valid constitutionally". The national Law Commission previous year sought public views on whether to abolish the practice, triggering a debate between politicians and religious leaders. Immediately after a few years of the death of Prophet Muhammad, the companions of Prophet Muhammad talked about triple talaq.

(Copyright © 2015. All Rights Reserved.)
 
Recommended

Rolf Harris to be released from Stafford Prison today
She said her sister did not believe Harris had assaulted her. "I told him to f*** off and leave me alone", she told the court. Should Rolf Harris have been released on bail? The jury has not been told why Harris was in prison or how long he served.

Hamilton wins Spanish GP ahead of Vettel
In a ding-dong contest, first Vettel forced Hamilton wide at Turn One after he emerged from his second stop next to the Mercedes . Daniel Ricciardo brought his Red Bull across in a distant third place to complete the podium, his best result of the season.

US trumpets Mosul gains, but Iraq says more aid needed
Flies swarmed over the charred remains of an Islamic State militant lying near a motorbike on a street in the district. The Iraqi government said last week the number of people fleeing Mosul had more than doubled to about 10,000 a day.

Slavisa Jokanovic: 'All to play for in semi-final second leg'
The full-back was not closed down quickly enough by Ryan Fredericks and drilled a low, angled drive in off the far post. We're playing with home advantage, but we're still playing against a very good side.

UN forces retake strategic areas of C. African Republic city
Early Saturday, another Moroccan soldier died in a similar attack on the base and a nearby Muslim-dominated area. "However credible sources have confirmed an undetermined number of civilian casualties", the statement said.

Europol says Global Cyberattack Affects 150 Countries
All it takes is for one computer on a network to be infected for all of the computers on that network to be compromised. But U.K. hospitals, Chinese universities and global firms like Fedex (FDX) also reported they had come under assault.

Trump Asked Comey to Shut Down Flynn Probe
The White House quickly responded to the Times story, claiming in a statement that 'the President has never asked Mr. Comey or anyone else to end any investigation, including any investigation involving General Flynn'.

Japan gets Ireland and Scotland at 2019 Rugby World Cup
Pool B consists of the current World Cup holders New Zealand plus former champions South Africa and Conor O'Shea's Italy . Pool B - New Zealand , South Africa , Italy , Africa 1, repechage victor .

Manchester United boss Jose Mourinho more focused on silverware than top four
Though they will miss out on the top four, Jose Mourinho's side will want to put an end to their four-game winless league run. One of his standout performances this term came against Premier League champions, Chelsea in January.

Wait, Kylie Jenner Makes Her Housekeeper Do WHAT?!
Granted, her luxe lifestyle would be on display, but how much would we get to see the *real* Kylie. She wants to feel protected and secure and Travis provides that.

Samsung Galaxy S8 Active Nears Launch As Smartphone Gets Wi-Fi Certification
The Samsung Galaxy S8 shines in the video recording segment where it comes out at the top with a sub-score of 88 points. Apart from South Korea, the phone is slated to be released in more markets soon after being released in the country.

Brad Pitt, Jennifer Aniston partner dead: 'Sopranos' producer
A small private funeral service will be held this week, followed by a memorial service scheduled in coming weeks. He leaves behind his wife, Cassandra and their son Jules, as well as three children from his previous marriage.

Sore ankle keeps Raptors G Lowry out of starting lineup
The 3-point line has been the difference as the Cleveland are outscoring the Toronto by a total of 51 points. The Cleveland Cavaliers went from trailing 77-72 to taking an 81-77 lead. "And we're a different team".

British Moors murderer Ian Brady dies in hospital
Brady and Hindley faced repeated calls to reveal where they hid the body of Keith Bennett, who went missing aged 12 in 1964. Eventually caught and jailed for life in 1966, Brady refused to tell the Bennett family where their son was buried.

South Korea recalls Hyundai cars, asks probe on cover-up
Hyundai said it respects the decision "though there have been no reported injuries or accidents from the cited issues". Hyundai and Kia have already incurred heavy losses from recalling cars equipped with defective Theta 2 engines.


More News

News
More News